Four Scary Stories is the 5th episode of Season 5 of Dawson's Creek.


Jen (Michelle Williams) takes over Charlie's (guest star Chad Michael Murray) nighttime shift on the radio and plays DJ to a host of listeners who call in with terrifying tales.


Katie Holmes as Joey Potter[1]
Michelle Williams as Jen Lindley
Joshua Jackson as Pacey Witter
Kerr Smith as Jack McPhee
Mary Beth Peil as Evelyn Ryan

Special Guest Stars

Busy Philipps as Audrey Liddell
Lourdes Benedicto as Karen Torres

Guest starring

Bryce Johnson as Library Guy
Jonah Blechman as Tad


  • This episode is chronologically the 5th episode of the season, but aired as the 9th due to the events of 11 September, 2001.
    • This is evident in Pacey's story featuring a very recent moment with Karen Torres, who left town in Hotel New Hampshire


complete me | EDMUND'S CROWN
pacey, jack and joey arrive at Grams'
it's gone | BLAKE MORGAN
song on the radio
jack in the attic
spin your head | THE ASHGROVE
jack returns to his room and the guy's gone
vinyl suits | SCHNOCKERED
pacey and karen
sweet dreams (are made of this) | MARILYN MANSON
jen at the radio station
goodnight moon | SHIVAREE
grams finishes her story

Notes and references

  1. This is the first episode of the series to not feature James Van Der Beek as protagonist Dawson Leery
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.